Why Are They So Stubborn: Changing Your Approach to Embrace Empathy

In the caregiving relationship, both caregivers and care receivers change. As the caregiver, you might feel like your loved one is giving you a hard time, reluctant to give up their driver’s license or accept help for tasks that were formerly a breeze for them. Perhaps you find yourself asking, "Why is the resistance so strong?" 

Answering this question requires a shift in perspective to see through their eyes. As we navigate changing dynamics, remember their life has been substantially impacted, gradually taking away their independence, bit by bit. It’s easy to get stuck in a pattern of thinking they are just being a problem or that if they went along with your plan, everything would be so much easier. That train of thought ignores the fact that you are caring for another person whose life is changing and may be beyond their control. Take a moment to think about what you would feel in their shoes. Regardless of your best intentions, this is difficult for your loved one. 

It's our responsibility as caregivers to exchange frustration for empathy, to comprehend their perspective alongside our own, and to engage in deep, honest conversations about the transformations we are all experiencing.

Turn Empathy into Frustration

In the face of resistance, frustration is a natural sentiment. Prolonged frustration, however, can turn into resentment or despair. This is where empathy, the capacity to comprehend and share another individual's feelings, comes in. It invites a greater understanding and patience for you as a caregiver and encourages a more loving, respectful relationship with your care recipient.

Remember, their frustration often stems from loss. The loss of physical capabilities, cognitive sharpness, and, most importantly, their independence. Before heart disease or arthritis or dementia, they were self-reliant individuals with bustling lives. To be suddenly dependent on someone else for fundamental tasks such as cooking or bathing can be psychologically difficult to wrestle with. 

Not to mention tasks that were once leisurely, such as driving, are no longer an option, causing a dent in their self-worth and creating a paradoxical sense of guilt for needing your help. This hurts, so naturally, resistance is one way people cope.

Remember, it’s Not About You

When met with moments of resistance from our loved ones, it's vital to catch ourselves if we begin thinking it's a personal attack. It’s not. It's merely their signal of frustration and feeling of constraint, clearly manifesting that their adaptation process is strenuous and challenging.

Engage in Honest and Deep Conversations

Demonstrating empathy isn’t limited to your own silent understanding. It incorporates direct, candid conversations about the changing dynamics. Address the changes you both are experiencing. Explain that you understand their frustration, acknowledge the dignity they feel they are losing, and reassure them that their value and importance have not diminished amidst the changes.

Having these conversations might be complicated, but they are necessary. Being open about changes allows for better acceptance and easier adaptation. Remember, this is a journey you are on together. You are there to support and uplift each other.

Empathy in Practice 

Implementing empathy into practice begins with compassion, patience, and understanding. 

  • Set aside personal frustration and focus on the root cause of their resistance. This process might require some deep introspection to allow it. You may even need a therapist to help you work through your own feelings on the situation to truly cope. 

  • Be patient. If they need extra time to accomplish a task independently rather than having you do it, give them that time as long as they are safe. 

  • Make sure you listen more than you speak. This means listening to understand the words they are saying, not just listening so you can plan how to make your next point. Encouraging them to express their feelings will help engage both of you in a dialogue about the shared experience rather than making them feel preached at or dictated to. 

  • Lastly, demonstrate your understanding. They need to know that their feelings are acknowledged and validated. If you only listen to them and don’t act on what they have shared, you aren’t making any progress. Your actions mean a great deal during this time. 

Caregiving is a complex and relentless task, but it can also be incredibly rewarding. The secret lies in turning challenges into opportunities for deeper connection and shared understanding. Empathy is the flashlight that allows us to navigate through the uncertainties of our caregiving journey, guiding us toward a more compassionate, understanding, and supportive care relationship.

As we walk this road together, let's remember to extend each other the precious gift of empathy. It's not about 'managing' or 'dealing' with our loved ones, but truly understanding and supporting them. We are, after all, on this journey of life together, and what better compass to have than empathy, the true north star of understanding, compassion, and love? Cheers to all caregivers out there making a difference here's to you and your empathetic heart braving through the unique journey of caregiving.